Military housing for gays and lesbians

The Commandant of the U.S. Marine Corps, the highest ranking officer in that branch of the service (if you ignore the fact that the Marine Corps is technically part of the U.S. Navy) has weighed in on the subject of changing the military’s “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell” policy. Though he will follow the President’s orders and the laws passed by Congress, he has publicly stated that he would not want to force a straight Marine to share a room with a gay Marine.

It’s a unique problem for the Marines, because they are the only military service that has military personnel on U.S. bases billet two-to-a-room.

“In this case, I would want to reserve the right of a Marine that thinks he or she wouldn’t want to [share a room with a homosexual]. And again that’s the overwhelming … number of people that say that they wouldn’t like to do so.”

The Marine Corps puts two people in a room together because it believes that it’s good for unit cohesion. The Commandant’s concern is that a gay Marine sharing a room with a straight one might have the opposite effect… And if that proves to be the case, then the Corps “will adopt the single-room standard of the other services.”

Marine Commandant Gen. James Conway

There’s an interesting poll posted on The Muster, which is’s daily poll. It asks respondents whether the Marine Commandant is right to worry about a gay marine and a straight marine sharing a room together. As of this afternoon, 55% of responses say that it would be a problem, while 45% say that it wouldn’t necessarily be one. Feel free to respond to the poll yourself, but I’d also love to hear your thoughts on this page too.

So here’s your chance… Should gay marines have their own separate housing, or is “separate but equal” not any more acceptable on matters of sexual orientation than it is on matters of race or religion? Reply below!

4 Responses to Military housing for gays and lesbians

  1. dane says:

    i think it should be a personal choice. if a straight marine doesn’t want to live with a gay marine, then naive as his opinion may be, it should be respected.

  2. gatoruptown says:

    Dane, what if that same marine didn’t want to share a room with someone who was of a different religion? Or whose skin color didn’t match his/hers? Where do you draw the line at roommate preferences? (Honest question, not being argumentative)

  3. dane says:

    i honestly believe that the same marine shouldn’t have to live with someone of a different religion or race if he didn’t want to. i personally don’t like bigotry, but it’s not my place (or anyone else’s) to tell someone what to believe so long as that person keeps his beliefs to himself.

  4. The decision to allow or not allow gays and lesbians to occupy military housing was decided when [they] were allowed to join the military.The MORAL issue of right verses wrong was established at the point of enlistment!To further restrict privileges given to all other enlistees would be a form of discrimination,and we all know the military is NOT allowed to do that. V/R John Steidley (USN-Ret)

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: